Tomato Garlic Cheddar

Made by
Milton Creamery
Tomato Garlic Cheddar is a creamy, handcrafted cheddar infused with real tomatoes and garlic for a savory, well-balanced flavor that’s perfect for sandwiches, melting, and charcuterie boards.

Made by

Milton Creamery

Milk Type

Cow

Tomato Garlic Cheddar is inspired by the simple, honest flavors of a farmhouse kitchen—where ripe tomatoes, fresh garlic, and creamy cheddar come together in dishes meant to be shared. This cheese was created for those who love bold flavor but still want balance, comfort, and versatility in every bite. By starting with a well-made cheddar and carefully blending in real tomato and garlic, the result is a cheese that feels familiar, savory, and deeply satisfying.

How it came to be

Cheddar has always been a natural foundation for added flavors because of its rich body and smooth melt. The idea behind Tomato Garlic Cheddar was to capture the taste of classic comfort foods—think baked pasta, grilled sandwiches, and warm casseroles—without overpowering the cheese itself. Using real tomato pieces and garlic granules allows the flavors to infuse naturally into the cheddar as it ages, creating a cohesive, well-rounded cheese rather than a surface-level seasoning.

What makes it unique

What sets Tomato Garlic Cheddar apart is its balance and authenticity. The tomato brings a subtle sweetness and gentle acidity, while the garlic adds warmth and depth without harshness. Neither ingredient dominates; instead, they enhance the cheddar’s natural creaminess. The result is a cheese that’s bold enough to stand on its own, yet versatile enough to melt, slice, or shred beautifully.

Flavor profile

  • First bite: smooth, creamy cheddar with mild tang
  • Mid-palate: savory tomato notes emerge, slightly sweet and rich
  • Finish: mellow garlic warmth with a lingering buttery cheddar finish
  • Overall: savory, comforting, and well-balanced—never sharp or overwhelming


Aroma

Inviting and familiar, with aromas of buttery cheddar, sun-ripened tomato, and a gentle hint of roasted garlic, reminiscent of a cozy kitchen in the middle of a home-cooked meal.


Texture & appearance

  • Texture: smooth and sliceable with a creamy mouthfeel; melts evenly and luxuriously
  • Appearance: pale yellow cheddar with visible red tomato pieces and fine garlic flecks throughout


Ingredients

Milk, tomatoes, garlic, salt, cheese cultures, enzymes.

(Always refer to the product label for the most accurate ingredient listing.)


Pairing suggestions

Charcuterie & snacks

  • Crusty Italian bread, focaccia, or toasted baguette
  • Salami, pepperoni, or roast turkey
  • Olives, roasted red peppers, or marinated artichokes

In the kitchen

  • Grilled cheese, paninis, and hot sandwiches
  • Melted over burgers, chicken, or roasted vegetables
  • Shredded into pasta bakes, omelets, or savory breads

Beverages

  • Amber ale, pale ale, or Italian-style pilsner
  • Light to medium-bodied red wines like Chianti or Barbera
  • Dry rosé or sparkling water with citrus

Cheese Style

Cheddar

Rennet Type

Vegetarian

Cheese Qualities

Flavored

Regional Style

American

Certifications

No rBST Guarantee

Availability

Wholesale
Retail
Questions For THE PRODUCING Cheesemaker?

Don't Be Shy!

Click Here To Send An Email
Click Here To Send An Email
While we strive for accuracy in our cheese descriptions, some details may not always be current or complete. For the most up-to-date information regarding ingredients, production methods, and dietary considerations, please consult the cheese producers directly.